Pin it
Let me share my grandmother's secret shrimp butter recipe that's been stealing the show at family gatherings for generations! After years of watching her make this for every special occasion I finally perfected her technique. That perfect blend of tender shrimp creamy butter and those special seasonings creates pure magic. The first time I served this at my own party everyone crowded around the bowl asking for the recipe!
Why This Recipe Is Special
This isn't your ordinary butter spread! The combination of perfectly cooked shrimp rich butter and those classic seasonings creates something absolutely irresistible. Last Christmas when I brought this to our family gathering my aunt who's been making her own version for years asked for my recipe. Even my seafood-skeptical cousin couldn't stop coming back for more!
What You'll Need
- For The Shrimp:
- Fresh raw shrimp peeled and deveined
- Good kosher salt
- Fresh clean water
- For The Butter Magic:
- High-quality unsalted butter softened
- Worcestershire sauce for depth
- Celery seed our secret ingredient
- Sweet paprika if you like
- Just a touch of cayenne for warmth
- Fresh lemon juice
- Salt and pepper to taste
Let's Start Cooking
- Cooking Those Shrimp
- First we'll gently poach our shrimp in salted water just until they turn pink. Quick into an ice bath they go keeps them tender! My grandmother always said the secret is not overcooking them.
- Creating The Base
- While the shrimp cool we'll whip that butter until it's light and fluffy. Adding each seasoning watching it transform into something spectacular. The kitchen starts smelling amazing!
- Bringing It Together
- After finely chopping our shrimp we fold everything together. This is where the magic happens watching it all come together into this beautiful pink-speckled spread!
Pin it
Making It Perfect
Want to know my secrets for the best shrimp butter? Always start with raw shrimp pre-cooked ones just don't have the same flavor. Let your butter get completely soft but not melted. And here's my favorite tip add the lemon juice last just a little at a time until it tastes bright but not tart!
Serving It Up
This spread deserves beautiful presentation! I love serving it in my grandmother's crystal dish with an array of crackers around it. For parties I'll often make butter rosettes and chill them individually. Sometimes I'll even stuff little cherry tomatoes with it for an elegant passed appetizer!
Make-Ahead Magic
Here's a great party tip you can make this a day or two ahead! Just keep it covered in the fridge and let it come to room temperature before serving. The flavors actually get even better after a day together. Though honestly in my house it rarely lasts that long everyone always wants to take some home!
Mix It Up
Don't be afraid to play with the flavors! Sometimes I'll add a touch of Old Bay seasoning gives it a Maryland twist. My spice-loving son adds extra cayenne to his portion. Once I made it with herbs and garlic absolute game changer! That's what makes cooking fun finding your perfect combination.
Pin it
Why This Recipe Matters
This shrimp butter has become more than just a recipe it's part of our family's celebration tradition! There's something so special about making the same dish that's graced our family gatherings for generations. My kids are learning to make it now watching carefully as I share all those little tips and tricks passed down from their great-grandmother.
The best part isn't just how delicious it is it's seeing everyone's faces light up when they taste it! Whether you're making it for a special occasion or just because you want to make an ordinary day feel special this never disappoints. And watching people discover this retro appetizer that's stood the test of time? That's what makes cooking so rewarding!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why cook shrimp with shells on?
Cooking shrimp with shells on enhances their flavor and makes them easier to peel. The shells contain flavor compounds that infuse into the meat during cooking.
- → Why soak the onion in water?
Soaking onion in cold water mellows its sharp flavor and removes some of the bite. This creates a more balanced flavor in the final spread.
- → Can I make this ahead?
Yes, you can refrigerate for up to 1 week or freeze for up to 1 month. Let come to room temperature and re-beat until creamy before serving.
- → Why pat the shrimp dry?
Excess moisture prevents the shrimp from incorporating properly into the butter. Dry shrimp ensures a better texture in the final spread.
- → Can I use pre-cooked shrimp?
Fresh shrimp is preferred for better flavor, but pre-cooked can work. Just be sure to chop them very finely and pat them dry before mixing.