Pin it
These pierogi started as a recipe from my Polish grandmother, written on a tattered index card full of her cooking wisdom! Every time I make them, the smell of those caramelized onions takes me right back to her kitchen. After years of practice, I've figured out all the little tricks that make them perfect every time. My kids love helping with the assembly line they say it's like making edible Play-Doh!
What Makes These Special
The magic's in that silky dough that's flexible enough to stretch but strong enough to hold all that filling. My neighbor watched me make them last week couldn't believe how the simple ingredients turned into something so incredible. That combo of farmer's cheese and potato filling gets all creamy when it cooks, and when you hit those bits of bacon and caramelized onion pure comfort food heaven!
Shopping List
- The Dough Base:
- Fresh flour
- Good butter
- Sour cream
- Farm eggs
- Fine salt
- Kitchen scale
- The Filling:
- Russet potatoes
- Farmer's cheese
- Sharp cheddar
- Green onions
- Crispy bacon
- Fresh spices
- For Sauce:
- Yellow onions
- More butter
- Fresh herbs
- Extra bacon
- Sour cream
Let's Cook
- Dough Magic
- Getting that dough just right is everything! Mix until it's sticky but smooth, then let it rest in the fridge gets nice and elastic that way. My grandmother always said good pierogi dough should feel like your earlobe when it's ready!
- Filling Dreams
- Those potatoes need to be really well mashed no lumps allowed! When you mix in the cheeses while everything's still warm, it gets so creamy and perfect. The bacon and green onions add these little pops of flavor throughout.
- Assembly Time
- Rolling and cutting the dough is like a meditation. Each circle gets a scoop of filling, then fold and pinch to seal. I love the rhythm of it, and how each one looks a little different but perfect in its own way.
- Sauce Magic
- Those onions slowly turning golden in butter fill the whole house with the most amazing smell! When you add the pierogi to that butter sauce, they get all glossy and beautiful. That's when everyone starts hovering around the kitchen!
Pin it
Kitchen Tricks
Here's what years of pierogi-making have taught me: weigh your flour using a scale it makes such a difference. Keep your hands floured but not your work surface the dough needs something to grip onto. And don't overfill one tablespoon is plenty, trust me! These little details make the difference between good pierogi and great ones.
Get Ready
Organization is key for pierogi making! I set up stations: one for rolling dough, one for filling, and one for the finished dumplings. Having everything ready before you start really helps the process flow. Plus, it's fun to get others involved my family loves assembly line pierogi making! Just keep those filled ones covered with a damp towel while you work.
Mix It Up
Once you've got the technique down, try different fillings! Sometimes I'll do sauerkraut and mushroom, or sweet farmer's cheese with a touch of sugar. My friend makes them with mashed sweet potatoes and sage says they're amazing. The dough recipe stays the same it's like a blank canvas for whatever flavors you love.
Time to Share
There's something so special about sharing homemade pierogi! I love watching people take that first bite seeing their eyes light up when they taste that perfect combo of crispy outside and creamy filling. These aren't just dumplings they're little packages of love, tradition, and comfort all wrapped up in dough.
Pin it
Family Tradition
Making pierogi has become such a cherished tradition in our house! Whether it's just us on a cozy weekend or a big gathering of friends and family, there's something magical about everyone pitching in to create these little dumplings. The kitchen gets messy, stories get shared, and memories are made. That's what good food is all about!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why do I need to weigh the flour?
- Weighing flour ensures consistent results in the dough. Cup measurements can vary significantly depending on how the flour is scooped, leading to dough that's too wet or dry.
- → Can I make pierogi ahead of time?
- You can make uncooked pierogi and refrigerate them for up to 4 hours or freeze them for up to a month. The filling and caramelized onions can also be made 3 days ahead.
- → What's the best substitute for farmer's cheese?
- Strained cottage cheese is the best substitute. Make sure to drain it well to avoid making the filling too wet. The texture should be crumbly but not dry.
- → How do I know when the pierogi are cooked?
- Pierogi will float to the surface when they're done boiling, usually after 4-5 minutes. Then pan-fry until golden brown for best texture and flavor.
- → Why do you need to save some cooking water?
- The starchy cooking water helps create a silky sauce when combined with the butter and caramelized onions. It helps the sauce coat the pierogi evenly.