Brisket Pot Pie with Cheddar

This hearty brisket pot pie transforms leftover brisket into a comforting, cheesy masterpiece that's perfect for Sunday dinners or special occasions. The combination of tender shredded meat and two kinds of melty cheese wrapped in flaky pastry creates an irresistible meal that brings everyone to the table.

I first created this recipe after smoking a brisket that was too large for our family gathering. The leftovers seemed too precious to waste, and this pot pie was born. Now my children specifically ask me to smoke extra brisket just so we can enjoy this cheesy pie a few days later.

• 1 pound shredded cooked brisket: provides the rich, smoky foundation that makes this dish special. Use leftover smoked brisket for the best flavor.
• 2 red bell peppers: add sweetness and bright color. Choose firm peppers with glossy skin for the freshest flavor.
• 1 onion: builds essential aromatic flavor. Yellow onions work perfectly here for their balance of sweetness and savoriness.
• 2 garlic cloves: infuse the filling with warmth. Fresh cloves offer much better flavor than pre-minced options.
• 1 cup shredded cheddar cheese: brings sharp, tangy notes. Choose aged cheddar for more complex flavor.
• ½ cup Monterey Jack cheese: adds a creamy, melty texture that perfectly complements the sharper cheddar.
• ¼ cup all purpose flour: thickens the sauce to perfect consistency. Measure carefully to avoid a gummy filling.
• ½ cup beef broth: adds depth and savory richness. Homemade is best, but a good quality store bought works well.
• ½ cup heavy cream: creates luxurious richness and helps bind the filling together.
• ½ teaspoon dried thyme: adds an earthy, aromatic element. Rub between your fingers before adding to release more flavor.
• 2 teaspoons salt: enhances all the flavors. Diamond Crystal kosher salt is recommended for its clean taste.
• ¼ teaspoon black pepper: adds subtle heat. Freshly ground provides the most vibrant flavor.
• 2 pie crusts: encase all the delicious filling. Store bought saves time, but homemade delivers superior flakiness.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Preheat Your Oven:

Begin by heating your oven to 375°F. This temperature creates the perfect balance of browning the crust while thoroughly heating the filling. Allow at least 20 minutes for most ovens to fully preheat to ensure consistent cooking.

Sauté the Aromatics:

Heat a large skillet over medium heat and add a tablespoon of butter or oil. Add your diced onion and minced garlic, stirring frequently to prevent burning. Cook for approximately 3 minutes until they become translucent and fragrant. The onions should soften but not brown. Add the red bell peppers and continue cooking for 2 more minutes until slightly softened but still maintaining some texture.

Prepare the Roux:

Sprinkle the flour evenly over the vegetable mixture, stirring constantly to prevent clumping. Continue cooking for one full minute, which is essential for removing the raw flour taste. The mixture will become paste-like and coat the vegetables. Gradually pour in the beef broth while continuously stirring, followed by the heavy cream. Keep stirring until the sauce begins to thicken, which typically takes 2 to 3 minutes. You'll know it's ready when it coats the back of a spoon.

Add the Brisket and Cheeses:

Reduce the heat to low and fold in your shredded brisket, ensuring it's evenly distributed throughout the sauce. Add both cheeses gradually, stirring until completely melted and incorporated. The mixture should become gloriously creamy and cohesive. Sprinkle in the thyme, salt, and pepper, adjusting seasonings to taste. The filling should be rich and well seasoned, as the crust will dilute the flavors slightly.

Assemble the Pie:

On a lightly floured surface, roll out one pie crust to about 12 inches in diameter to ensure it fits your pie plate with some overhang. Carefully transfer it to a 9 inch pie plate, gently pressing it into the corners without stretching the dough. Pour the entire brisket filling into the crust, mounding it slightly in the center. Roll out the second crust and place it over the filling. Trim any excess dough to about ½ inch overhang, then fold the edge of the top crust under the bottom crust and crimp decoratively to seal. Cut 4 to 5 small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.

Bake the Pot Pie:

Place the assembled pie on a baking sheet to catch any potential overflow. Bake in your preheated oven for 35 to 40 minutes, rotating halfway through for even browning. The crust should become deeply golden brown, and you should see the filling bubbling through the slits. If the crust edges brown too quickly, cover them with foil to prevent burning.

Pin it

The secret to this recipe's success is definitely the combination of cheeses. I discovered this perfect ratio after much experimentation, finding that the sharpness of cheddar paired with the meltability of Monterey Jack creates the ideal cheese sauce. My husband, usually skeptical of leftovers, now specifically requests that I smoke extra brisket just so we can enjoy this pot pie a few days later.

Storage and Reheating

This brisket pot pie keeps wonderfully in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Cover any leftover pie loosely with foil and refrigerate once completely cooled. For best results, reheat individual slices in a 325°F oven for about 15 minutes, or until heated through. Microwaving works in a pinch, but the crust will lose some of its crispness. If freezing, wrap the unbaked assembled pie tightly in plastic wrap and then foil. Freeze for up to 3 months and bake directly from frozen, adding an extra 15 to 20 minutes to the baking time.

Pin it

Make It Your Own

This versatile recipe welcomes thoughtful adaptations based on what you have available. No brisket? Substitute pulled pork, shredded chicken, or even leftover pot roast. The cheese combination can be customized to your preference. Sharp white cheddar and Gruyère create a more sophisticated flavor profile, while pepper jack adds a pleasant heat. For vegetable variations, mushrooms add earthy depth, while carrots or peas bring color and sweetness. Consider adding a tablespoon of Dijon mustard or Worcestershire sauce to the filling for an additional flavor dimension that complements the richness of the meat and cheese.

Perfect Pairings

Serve this rich pot pie with something acidic to balance its decadence. A simple green salad dressed with vinaigrette cuts through the richness perfectly. For beverage pairings, a robust red wine like Zinfandel or Syrah stands up beautifully to the smoky brisket, while a hoppy IPA offers refreshing contrast. During cooler months, serve smaller portions of the pie alongside a cup of tomato soup for a comforting meal that satisfies without overwhelming.

The Cultural Roots

This recipe represents a beautiful fusion of classic American comfort food traditions. Pot pies have been a staple in American kitchens since colonial times, while smoked brisket has deep roots in Texas barbecue culture. By combining these beloved traditions, this dish honors both home cooking heritage and regional barbecue mastery. The addition of two distinct cheeses reflects the American love affair with dairy richness, creating a pot pie that feels simultaneously innovative and familiar.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What kind of brisket works best?

Cooked, shredded brisket with a smoky, savory profile works best for this dish. You can use leftovers or prepare a fresh brisket for a more robust flavor.

→ What can I use instead of heavy cream?

For a lighter option, you can substitute heavy cream with half-and-half or whole milk mixed with a teaspoon of cornstarch for thickness.

→ Can I make the pie crust from scratch?

Absolutely! Homemade pie crust adds an extra layer of flavor. However, store-bought crusts are a convenient and equally delicious option.

→ How do I keep the crust flaky and golden?

Brushing the crust with a beaten egg wash before baking ensures a glossy, golden finish. Avoid overworking the dough if making it from scratch to maintain flakiness.

→ What other cheese can I use?

If you don't have cheddar or Monterey Jack, feel free to use Gruyere, mozzarella, or even a sharp Gouda for a unique twist.

→ Can I add other vegetables?

Yes! Feel free to add vegetables like carrots, peas, or mushrooms for additional flavor and texture.